Clinical Research
Tinnitus in children attract more attention. Kentish et
al. data show that tinnitus can have the same impact on children lives as in
adults. Notably, children with hearing
loss found tinnitus less troublesome that children with normal hearing.
As majority of epidemiological data were gathered in UK,
Germany, and Sweden, there is still great need for epidemiological data from
various countries. Vallianatou et al.,
report preliminary data from Greece. Results from Brazil (Pitcher et al.) describe prevalence of
sensorineural hearing loss and tinnitus in patients with sickle cell, showing
the presence of positive correlation.
The recurrent question of tinnitus treatment with
low-intensity laser was addressed in randomized, prospective, double-blind,
placebo-controlled trial (Mirz et al.).
As in previous well controlled studies, there was no positive effect of
laser, and the authors conclude that previous positive reports may be explained
by the placebo effect.
There is no consensus on the method to evaluate tinnitus. Two
studies were aimed at checking relative validity of various
questionnaires. Baguley et al.,
evaluated correlation of findings from the tinnitus handicap inventory (THI)
with tinnitus questionnaire (TQ), and concluded that both questionnaires
provide convergent results. Meric et
al., studied English and French version of Tinnitus Reaction Questionnaire and
concluded that French version is equally valid as English original.
Children's experience of
tinnitus: a preliminary survey of children presenting to a psychology
department. Kentish RC, Crocker SR, McKenna
L. Nuffield Hearing and Speech Centre,
Royal National Throat, Nose and Ear Hospital, London, UK. Br J Audiol 2000 Dec;34(6):335_40
Tinnitus has been much researched within adult populations
with consideration of prevalence as well as the impact of tinnitus on
individual's lives. Although the literature highlights the prevalence of
tinnitus in children, there is little information on its effects from a
psychological perspective. This small_scale preliminary study looked at 24
children (50% with normal hearing and 50% with a hearing loss) who presented to
the Psychology Department with troublesome tinnitus. In line with adult
studies, preliminary results suggested that tinnitus can have as marked an effect
on children's lives as it is reported to have on adults. Insomnia, emotional
distress, listening and attention difficulties are the main psychological
factors associated with tinnitus in children. These, in turn, may have an
effect upon their school performance. Differences were found between children
with normal hearing and those with some degree of hearing loss. Overall,
children with normal hearing found tinnitus more troublesome and presented with
higher levels of anxiety than those with some level of hearing impairment. The
present study suggests that children who complain of tinnitus should be taken
seriously. In terms of management, individual intervention packages were found
to be useful in alleviating anxiety and other associated factors. Recommendations
are made on areas for future research.
Audiologic and
psychological profile of Greek patients with tinnitus_Preliminary findings. Vallianatou NG, Christodoulou P, Nestoros
JN, Helidonis E. Department of
Otorhinolaryngology, Laboratory of Audiology and Neurotology, University
Hospital of Heraklion, Crete, Greece.
Am J Otolaryngol 2001 Jan_Feb;22(1):33_7
Tinnitus is a common complaint among people who suffer from
auditory disorders. Altering the patients' response to tinnitus and the
development of coping techniques are the most important goals of the
therapeutic or suppression methods. This is the first study in the Greek
population to investigate the personality characteristics and coping techniques
of tinnitus patients. We have studied the relation between the subjective
assessment of tinnitus intensity with factors such as sex, age, duration of
symptom, and degree of hearing loss. We have also studied the possible relation
between the patients' personality characteristics on their attitude towards
tinnitus. The participants were 80 tinnitus sufferers, men and women, between
18 and 65 years of age. The personality characteristics were assessed with the
Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). The mean MMPI scores in
both men and women were within the normal range. The duration of symptoms did
not prove to be an important factor for the patients' subjective assessment of
the tinnitus intensity. Most patients showed "effective" coping
style, were well adjusted to tinnitus, and had no significant interference in
their everyday functioning. The above are discussed in the context of the
influence of geographical, climatological, economic, social, and cultural
factors that influence psychological functioning.
Sensorineural hearing
loss among sickle cell disease patients from southern Brazil. Piltcher.
O, Cigana L, Friedriech J, Ribeiro FA, da Costa SS. Hospital de Clinicas de Porto Alegre and the
Faculdade de Ciencias Medicas da Santa Casa de Sao Paulo, Brazil. Am J Otolaryngol 2000 Mar_Apr;21(2):75_9
PURPOSE: A case_control study was done to confirm the higher
prevalence of sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) among sickle cell patients
(HbSS) from southern Brazil. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Twenty_eight patients and 28
matched normal controls were studied. Besides complete anamneses and physical
otolaryngological examination, all individuals had audiometric and
tympanometric testings to determine the presence of SNHL or middle ear
problems. The only significant difference between groups was the presence of a
positive history of otologic symptoms (hearing loss, dizziness or tinnitus) and
neurological sequelae in the HbSS patients. RESULTS: Six patients (21.4%)
presented with SNHL compared with one control (3.6%) (Fisher's one_tailed P =
.05; OR, 7.36 (95% CI, 0.82, 65.83). The average age of HbSS diagnosis was
higher among the patients with SNHL (10 years +/_ 8.3) than those without SNHL
(5.43 years +/_ 5.65), but this was not significant (analysis of variance P
> .05). More patients 25 years and older on the examination date had SNHL
than younger patients (Fisher's 2_tailed P < .05). Sixty_seven percent of
the patients with SNHL had alterations in the acoustic reflex, and a surprising
27% of the patients without NSHL also presented with some elevation or an
absence of acoustic reflex. CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate that patients with
HbSS from southern Brazil are more predisposed to the development of
sensorineural hearing problems than the general population.
[Treatment of tinnitus
with low_intensity laser]. [Article in Danish]
Mirz F, Zachariae B, Andersen SE, Nielsen AG, Johansen LV, Bjerring P,
Pedersen CB. Arhus
Universitetshospital, Arhus Kommunehospital, ore_naese_halsafdeling H.
mirz@dadlnet.dk Ugeskr Laeger 2000 Jun
19;162(25):3607_10
This study evaluated the effect of low_power laser in the
treatment of tinnitus in a randomized, prospective, double_blind,
placebo_controlled trial. The active laser applied 50 mW (cw, 830 nm) over a
period of 10 minutes per session. Forty_nine patients were included. The main
outcome was measured using psychoacoustical match of tinnitus loudness, Visual
Analog Scale (VAS) ratings of subjective loudness, annoyance and attention
involved, scores on tinnitus_specific questionnaires, and a number of psychosocial
questionnaires. Only few subjects (18%) experienced subjective improvement.
There were no statistically significant differences between the effects of the
active laser and placebo treatments. CONCLUSION: Low_power laser treatment is
not indicated in the treatment of tinnitus. Reports of significant benefits of
this treatment in previous studies may be explained by the placebo effect.
Convergent validity of
the tinnitus handicap inventory and the tinnitus questionnaire. Baguley DM, Humphriss RL, Hodgson CA. Department of Audiology, Addenbrooke's
Hospital, Cambridge, UK. dmb29@cam.ac.uk
J Laryngol Otol 2000 Nov;114(11):840_3
For research into tinnitus to be robust and credible, the use
of well_validated instruments of self_perceived tinnitus handicap as outcome
measures is essential. The tinnitus handicap inventory (THI) and the tinnitus
questionnaire (TQ) are two such instruments which are in widespread use. Both
questionnaires were administered by mail to 100 consecutive new patients of the
Cambridge Tinnitus Clinic, and completed in randomized order. These patients
had been referred by the otolaryngology team and had not undergone any tinnitus
therapy. The response rate was 78 per cent, neither questionnaire being more
acceptable to patients than the other. The convergent validity of the
instruments was high, with total and subscale scores all being significantly
correlated at the five per cent level (Spearman correlation coefficients). A
number of subscale scores were not significantly correlated at the one per cent
level however. In particular, the sleep disturbance element of the TQ was
demonstrated to have some discriminant validity from the THI and from other
elements of the TQ at the one per cent significance level. The THI and TQ have
been demonstrated to have high convergent validity and are both suitable for
tinnitus outcome studies involving the quantification of self_perceived
tinnitus handicap. For research that aims to determine the specific effect of
an intervention on tinnitus_related sleep disturbance, the TQ sleep subscale
has potential utility. The hypothetical constructs of tinnitus handicap
underlying the psychologist_developed TQ and the audiologist_developed THI have
been shown to be convergent.
Validation assessment of
a French version of the tinnitus reaction questionnaire: a comparison between
data from English and French versions.
Meric C, Pham E, Chery_Croze S.
UMR CNRS, Lyon,
France. J Speech Lang Hear Res 2000
Feb;43(1):184_90
The present study compares the results obtained on original
and French versions of the TRQ (Tinnitus Reaction Questionnaire) initially
published by Wilson, Henry, Bowen, and Haralambous (1991) in English to
evaluate the psychological distress of tinnitus sufferers. Reliability and
validity of the French translation were determined using data from 173 normal
hearing or hearing_impaired patients with tinnitus lasting from 1 month to 41
years. They completed the translated questionnaire and a short version of the
Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory. The results indicated good
internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha = .94), and the reliability of the
French version of the TRQ was demonstrated, except for items 5 and 20. High
statistically significant correlations were found between the TRQ and
Depression, Psychaesthenia, and Anxiety Mini_Mult subscales. The validation
demonstrates only minor effects of language. The French version of the TRQ thus
is an equally valid tool as the original English version for evaluating
tinnitus distress of a patient.
Audiology
The variability of repetitive evaluation of tinnitus
loudness was proposed as one of method to validate the presence of tinnitus
(particularly for legal cases).
Jacobson et al. have shown that the underlying this approach assumption
of larger variability in people who imagine tinnitus, versus those who actually
experience it, is not correct, and consequently study of the variability has no
value for proving existence of tinnitus.
On the technical side Henry at al., proposed a computerized system for
psychoacoustical tinnitus evaluation.
Another paper from Henry & Meikle confirmed one of
postulates of the neurophysiological model of tinnitus that neither loudness
nor other psychoacoustic measures of tinnitus have a consistent relation to the
severity or perceived loudness of tinnitus.
On the other hand, Holgers et al., reports that severity of tinnitus,
measured by absence from work related to tinnitus, could be related to
depression and physical immobility.
Fowler et al., relate tinnitus severity to insomia, anxiety and
depression, furthermore making analogy to chronic pain.
Effects of unilateral sudden hearing loss were investigated
by Chiossoine-Kerdel et al. Tinnitus
was found in 67% of cases with handicap present in 57% of subject with
tinnitus. Hearing handicap was noted in
86% of patients. Notably, there was no
correlation between the extent of audiometric loss and hearing or tinnitus
handicap. The authors concluded that
handicap in these patients results form both tinnitus and hearing loss.
Interesting occupational hearing loss was reported by
Merchant at al., in rickshaw drivers.
In addition to heairng loss they were twice as likely to develop
tinnitus.
Attempt to detect some features related to tinnitus in DPOAE
was reported by Linke et al.
Unfortunately, the authors were not able to document any positive
findings.
Katzenell & Segal review literature related to
hyperacusis, list various medical problems and conditions accompanied by
hyperacusis, and suggest dominance of central mechanism.
A re_evaluation of
tinnitus reliability testing. Jacobson GP,
Henderson JA, McCaslin DL. Division of
Audiology, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, Michigan 48202, USA. J Am Acad Audiol 2000 Mar;11(3):156_61
The purposes of these investigations were to (1) evaluate
tinnitus loudness measures of unskilled normal listeners asked to imagine that
they are experiencing a constant monaural tonal tinnitus and (2) compare the
performance of these listeners to that of a sample of patients with tinnitus.
Subgroups of 24 patients participated in two investigations. Results suggest
that (1) normal subjects asked to imagine a high_pitched, tonal tinnitus show
significantly greater tinnitus loudness matching levels (a) when they do not
have an external reference, (b) after a 1_week interval, and (c) for
low_frequency matching tones; (2) patients with high_pitched tinnitus did not
demonstrate statistically significant differences in tinnitus loudness
judgments within or between sessions or frequencies; (3) tinnitus patients do
not differ significantly from normals feigning tinnitus in the variability of
tinnitus loudness matching levels within a single session (two measures) or after
a 1_week interval (one measure); and (4) normals feigning tinnitus tended to
choose significantly greater loudness matching levels than did tinnitus
subjects.
Computer_automated
clinical technique for tinnitus quantification.
Henry JA, Fausti SA, Flick CL, Helt WJ, Ellingson RM. Veterans Affairs RR&D National Center
for Rehabilitative Auditory Research, Portland VA Medical Center, OR, USA.
henryj@ohsu.edu Am J Audiol 2000
Jun;9(1):36_49
This study addresses the need for uniformity in techniques for
clinical quantification of tinnitus. Because automation can be an effective
means to achieve standardization, this laboratory is developing techniques to
perform computer_automated tinnitus testing. The present study was conducted to
demonstrate the feasibility of obtaining reliable tinnitus measures using a
fully automated system. A computer_controlled psychoacoustical system was
developed to quantify tinnitus loudness and pitch using a tone_matching
technique. Hearing thresholds were also obtained as part of the procedure. The
system generated test stimuli and simultaneously controlled a notebook computer
positioned in the sound chamber facing the patient. The notebook computer
displayed instructions for responding and relayed response choices through on_screen
"buttons" that the patient touched with a pen device. Twenty
individuals with tinnitus were evaluated with the technique over two sessions,
and responses were analyzed for test_retest reliability. Analyses revealed good
reliability of thresholds, loudness matches, and pitch matches. These results
demonstrate that use of a fully automated system to obtain reliable
measurements of tinnitus loudness and pitch is feasible for clinical
application.
Psychoacoustic measures
of tinnitus. Henry JA, Meikle MB. VA RR&D National Center for
Rehabilitative Auditory Research, Portland VA Medical Center, Oregon 97207,
USA. J Am Acad Audiol 2000
Mar;11(3):138_55
This report reviews research from the 1930s to the present
that has extended our understanding by investigating the characteristics of
tinnitus that can be studied using psychoacoustic techniques. Studies of
tinnitus masking and residual inhibition began in the 1970s, leading to the
therapeutic use of tinnitus masking and a consequent increase in research
devoted to tinnitus measurement. In 1981, the CIBA Foundation symposium on
tinnitus advocated general adoption of four tinnitus measures: (1) pitch, (2)
loudness, (3) maskability, and (4) residual inhibition. Since then,
psychoacoustic research into all four topics has proliferated, yielding many
valuable insights and controversies concerning the details of measurement
techniques. A consensus has emerged that neither the loudness nor other
psychoacoustic measures of tinnitus bear a consistent relation to the severity
or perceived loudness of tinnitus. Nevertheless, quantification is needed in
clinical trials of proposed treatments and in a variety of other types of
tinnitus research. Standardization of techniques for specifying the acoustic
parameters of tinnitus thus continues to be an important research goal.
Predictive factors for
the severity of tinnitus Holgers KM,
Erlandsson SI, Barrenas ML.
Department of Audiology,
Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Goteborg University, Sweden. Audiology 2000 Sep;39(5):284_91
The majority of patients with tinnitus experience a lessening
of their symptoms during an 18_month period after their first consultation. The
exception to this rule is severe incapacitating tinnitus, the sometimes very
troublesome symptoms of which show no sign of diminishing with time. The aim of
the present study was to investigate risk factors for incapacitating tinnitus,
as measured by absence from work related to tinnitus (AWT) of more than 1 month
during an 18_month period after the first visit to the tinnitus clinic.
Audiometric data and the scores from the Tinnitus Severity Questionnaire and
the Nottingham Health Profile at the first visit to the clinic were correlated
to AWT by a logistic regression model. By using this risk model, an individual
risk score for AWT could be estimated. Depression and physical immobility were
strong predictors of AWT, and hearing loss was moderate. Based on these
results, we suggest that the aetiology of tinnitus severity could be described
as depression_/anxiety_related, somatic, and auditory tinnitus.
Chronic tinnitus as
phantom auditory pain. Folmer RL, Griest
SE, Martin WH. Tinnitus Clinic, Oregon
Hearing Research Center, Department of Otolaryngology, Oregon Health Sciences
University. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg
2001 Apr;124(4):394_400
OBJECTIVES: To investigate similarities between patients who
experience chronic tinnitus or pain and to formulate treatment strategies that
are likely to be effective for patients who experience phantom auditory pain. Study
design: A total of 160 patients rated the severity and loudness of their
tinnitus and completed the State_Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) and an
abbreviated version of the Beck Depression Inventory (aBDI). Patients received
counseling, audiometric testing, and matched the loudness of their tinnitus to
sounds played through headphones. SETTING: A specialized tinnitus clinic within
an urban medical center. RESULTS: Tinnitus severity was highly correlated with
patients' degree of sleep disturbance, STAI, and aBDI scores. The self_rated
(on a 1_to_10 scale)_but not the matched_loudness of tinnitus was correlated
with tinnitus severity, sleep disturbance, STAI, and aBDI scores. CONCLUSIONS:
The severity of chronic tinnitus is correlated with the severity of insomnia,
anxiety, and depression. These relationships are the same for many patients
with chronic pain. Treatment recommendations are discussed in reference to
these results.
An investigation of the
audiologic handicap associated with unilateral sudden sensorineural hearing
loss. Chiossoine_Kerdel JA, Baguley DM, Stoddart
RL, Moffat DA. Department of
Otolaryngology, Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, UK. Am J Otol 2000 Sep;21(5):645_51
OBJECTIVE: To determine the incidence of tinnitus and
associated handicap after unilateral sudden sensorineural hearing loss (SSNHL);
in addition, to determine the hearing handicap experienced as a consequence of
such a loss. STUDY DESIGN: Identification of patients and determination of
demographic and audiologic data by retrospective case review; determination of
handicap and distress by postal questionnaire. SETTING: Teaching hospital
department of otolaryngology. PATIENTS: Thirty_eight patients were identified
as having been treated for a unilateral sudden sensorineural hearing loss in
the period 1988 through 1997. Of those, 21 (55.3%) replied to the
questionnaire. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Audiometric data at admission and at
4_week follow_up, Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI), visual analogue scales of
tinnitus loudness and distress, Hearing Handicap Inventory in Adults (HHIA).
RESULTS: The questionnaire responder group did not significantly differ from
the questionnaire nonresponder group on demographic nor audiometric variables,
and hence were considered to be a representative sample. Tinnitus was present
in 14 patients (67%). Hearing handicap was found in 86% of patients (of the 21
questionnaire responders) and tinnitus handicap in 57% (of the 14 with
tinnitus). Correlations were found between tinnitus loudness, distress, and
handicap. There was no correlation between time elapsed since SSNHL and
tinnitus or hearing handicap, nor was there a correlation between the extent of
audiometric loss and hearing or tinnitus handicap. A strong negative
correlation was, however, found between recovery in audiometry in the first 4
weeks after onset and tinnitus and hearing handicap. The audiometric status of
the contralateral ear correlated with hearing handicap. CONCLUSIONS: A majority
of patients after unilateral SSNHL have a perceived handicap associated with
tinnitus and hearing. Although this condition is an otologic emergency, careful
thought should be given to the audiologic rehabilitation of this patient group.
[Distortion products of
otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE) in acute tinnitus aurium]. [Article in German] Linke R, Mazurek B, Matschke RG. Hals_Nasen_Ohren_Klinik, Klinikum
Schwerin. Laryngorhinootologie 2000
Sep;79(9):517_22
BACKGROUND: The origin of subjective tinnitus is not really
known yet. It is possible to investigate the function of outer hair cells by
means of the distortion products of otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE). METHODS:
DPOAE of 56 patients were analysed in a prospective study (tinnitus without any
loss of hearing n = 34; hearing loss with a maximum of 35 dB and tinnitus n =
22). There was always a normal tympanogram and in no case a conductive hearing
loss. The relation of the primary tones f2/f1 was 1.22, the levels of the
primary tones were 70 dB. RESULTS: DPOAE_amplitudes were reduced distinctly in
both groups of patients. But there was no general difference and no difference
at the frequency of tinnitus between the ear with tinnitus and the
contralateral ear (no hearing loss) or there was a small reduction related to
the normal ear (distinct hearing loss). DPOAE_amplitudes did not change in
patients without hearing loss after a treatment with Pentoxifylline i.v., also
not at the frequency of tinnitus, although there was a subjective reduction of
tinnitus. In patients with hearing loss DPOAE_amplitudes enhanced like the
improvement of hearing threshold at the frequency of tinnitus. CONCLUSIONS: The
low DPOAE_amplitudes are a sign of damaged outer hair cells of the patients.
But there is a symmetry of the DPOAE_amplitudes and there is no change of DPOAE
after a therapy with Pentoxifylline i.v. in patients without hearing loss.
Hyperacusis: review and
clinical guidelines. Katzenell U, Segal
S. Department of Otolaryngology,
Wolfson Medical Center, Holon, Israel.
katzudi@zahav.net.il Otol
Neurotol 2001 May;22(3):321_6; discussion 326_7
OBJECTIVE: To review the current known causes of hyperacusis
and the different hypotheses concerning its etiology, and to suggest clinical
guidelines. DATA SOURCE: A review of the literature with the aid of the MEDLINE
database, using the following key words: hyperacusis, intolerance to sound,
loudness discomfort level, and phonophobia. DATA EXTRACTION: The data collected
included clinical studies, case reports and laboratory studies. CONCLUSION:
Hyperacusis was shown to be caused by pathologic conditions of the peripheral
auditory system, diseases of the central nervous system diseases, and hormonal
and infectious diseases. In some cases there was no known cause. The
pathophysiology of hyperacusis probably involves a central mechanism rather
than a peripheral one. Suggested clinical guidelines and treatment are
discussed.
Habituation based
therapies
Two contrasting papers were published recently; one
representing group of German psychologist strongly criticizing TRT, and the
other by PJ & MM Jastreboff providing outline of the present status of the
method. Future will show if “German concept”
or TRT survive the test of time.
[An assessment of
tinnitus retraining therapy]. [Article in German] von Wedel H, von Wedel UC. Abteilung fur Audiologie und Padaudiologie,
Klinik und Poliklinik fur Hals_, Nasen_ und Ohrenheilkunde der Universitat zu
Koln, Joseph Stelzmann_Strasse 9, 50924 Koln. hasso.von.wedel@uni_koeln.de HNO 2000 Dec;48(12):887_901
Based on the neurophysiological model of tinnitus developed
by Jastreboff and Hazell [39] there have been some important developments in
understanding and therapy of tinnitus over the last decade. The clinical
applications of this model are known as "tinnitus retraining
therapy", which has the objective of reducing both the distress associated
with tinnitus and the tinnitus perception itself. As a form of systematic,
repeated and skilled counselling over a long period of up to 2 years supported
by sound therapy (hearing aid or noise generator) the evidence for their high
degree of effectiveness is overwhelming. On the basis of a "German
concept" of tinnitus retraining therapy developed and proposed by the
ADANO (Arbeitsgemeinschaft deutschsprachiger Audiologen und Neurootologen) the
current status of this treatment will be briefly reviewed including some actual
studies of Goebel et al. [14] that confirm the world wide critical comments on the
recent developments in the management of tinnitus especially with regard to
tinnitus retraining therapy [79].
Tinnitus Retraining
Therapy (TRT) as a method for treatment of tinnitus and hyperacusis patients. Jastreboff PJ, Jastreboff MM. Tinnitus and Hyperacusis Center, Department
of Otolaryngology, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, Georgia 30322,
USA. J Am Acad Audiol 2000
Mar;11(3):162_77
The aim of this paper is to provide information about the
neurophysiologic model of tinnitus and Tinnitus Retraining Therapy (TRT). With
this overview of the model and therapy, professionals may discern with this
basic foundation of knowledge whether they wish to pursue learning and
subsequently implement TRT in their practice. This paper provides an overview
only and is insufficient for the implementation of TRT.
Pharmacology
Treating tinnitus with medications attract would be very
welcome, however so far none of the drugs pass the test of offering clear help
without profound side effects. A case report presents potential beneficial
effect of gabapentin (Zapp) while detailed, well controlled study dispose with
hope of effectiveness of Ginkgo biloba (Drew & Davies).
The list of drug reported to have tinnitus as a side effect
is long. Valproate is reported to
induce tinnitus which disappear after discontinuation of the drug which
indicates potential causal relation (Reeves et al.). This finding is of interest as the drug is used for treatment of
bipolar disorder, which would make tinnitus treatment more complex.
So far no medications were reported to be effective for
hyperacusis. A case study (Gopat et
al.) suggest potential for use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors,
which are cominly used as antidepressant.
While typical hyperacusis is relatively easy treated and cured with TRT,
it is more difficult when hyperacusis is accompanied by hypersensitivity in
other sensory modalities. Therefore, if
this finding is confirmed by double blind study, this would be of clear
interest.
Gabapentin for the
treatment of tinnitus: a case report.
Zapp JJ. Pain Institute of
Northeast Florida, 2021 Kingsley Ave., Suite 102, Orange Park, FL 32073, USA. Ear Nose Throat J 2001 Feb;80(2):114_6
The objective of this article is to discuss the clinically
effective use of gabapentin in patients with tinnitus. The author describes the
case of a man who came to the office complaining of tinnitus of 10 months'
duration. The patient was started on gabapentin and maintained on a regimen of
500 mg/day in divided doses. Subsequently, he reported that he was free of
tinnitus approximately 23 days a month and that he experienced a 75% decrease
in symptoms during the remaining days. At 2 years' follow_up, he remains noise_
and pain_free on 500 mg/day of gabapentin.
Effectiveness of Ginkgo
biloba in treating tinnitus: double blind, placebo controlled trial. Drew S, Davies E. Pharmacology Department, Division of Neuroscience, University of
Birmingham, Birmingham B15 2TT, UK. s.j.drew@bham.ac.uk BMJ 2001 Jan 13;322(7278):73
OBJECTIVE: To determine whether Ginkgo biloba is effective in
treating tinnitus. DESIGN: Double blind, placebo controlled trial using postal
questionnaires. PARTICIPANTS: 1121 healthy people aged between 18 and 70 years
with tinnitus that was comparatively stable; 978 participants were matched (489
pairs). Intervention: 12 weeks' treatment with either 50 mg Ginkgo biloba
extract LI 1370 three times daily or placebo. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES:
Participants' assessment of tinnitus before, during, and after treatment.
Questionnaires included items assessing perception of how loud and how
troublesome tinnitus was. Changes in loudness were rated on a six point scale.
Changes in how troublesome were rated on a five point scale. RESULTS: There
were no significant differences in primary or secondary outcome measures
between the groups. 34 of 360 participants receiving active treatment reported
that their tinnitus was less troublesome after 12 weeks of treatment compared
with 35 of 360 participants who took placebo. CONCLUSIONS: 50 mg Ginkgo biloba
extract LI 1370 given 3 times daily for 12 weeks is no more effective than
placebo in treating tinnitus.
Valproate_induced
tinnitus misinterpreted as psychotic symptoms.
Reeves RR, Mustain DW, Pendarvis JE.
Department of Psychiatry, Montgomery VA Medical Center, USA. South Med J 2000 Oct;93(10):1030_1
Valproate sodium is an anticonvulsant medication, which has
also been shown to be effective in the treatment of bipolar disorder. We report
a case of valproate_induced tinnitus that was initially misinterpreted as
increasing psychotic symptoms, which began approximately 2 days after
initiation of valproate therapy. Tinnitus worsened during the next 6 days of
treatment until it was recognized that this symptom was related to valproate.
After discontinuance of the medication, the tinnitus gradually resolved over a
period of 10 days with no residual effects. Although it is a rare adverse
effect, valproate_induced tinnitus should be included in the differential
diagnosis for tinnitus in patients receiving this medication. Tinnitus may be
difficult to recognize in patients with active psychosis or mania.
Effects of selective
serotonin reuptake inhibitors on auditory processing: case study. Gopal KV, Daly DM, Daniloff RG, Pennartz
L. Department of Speech and Hearing
Sciences, University of North Texas, Denton 76203, USA. J Am Acad Audiol 2000 Sep;11(8):454_63
Auditory sensitivity and processing ability were evaluated in
a patient who suffered from hyperacusis, difficulty understanding speech,
withdrawn depression, lethargy, and hypersensitivity to touch, pressure, and
light. Treatment with fluvoxamine and fluoxetine (selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors) reversibly alleviated complaints. Testing while medicated and
unmedicated (after voluntary withdrawal from medication for several weeks)
revealed no difference in pure_tone thresholds, speech thresholds, word
recognition scores, tympanograms, or acoustic reflex thresholds. Medicated
SCAN_A (a screening test for central auditory processing disorders) results
were normal, and unmedicated results were abnormal. Unmedicated transient
otoacoustic emissions and auditory brainstem response waves I, III, and V were
significantly larger bilaterally. Uncomfortable loudness levels indicated
greater tolerance during the medicated condition. Central processing and
vigilance were evaluated with analog_synthesized three_formant consonant_vowel
syllables. While medicated, responses to stimuli at each ear revealed
well_defined, labeling crossovers of about 90 msec. Vowel identification
matched normal subject responses; labeling of /gE/jE/ and /bE/wE/ continua was
well defined but all crossover points differed from normals (p < .0001).
During unmedicated testing, responses to /gE/jE/ began at medicated levels but
approached chance levels for the entire continuum within 10 min; labeling of
/bE/wE/ was consistent with medicated responses throughout with earlier than
normal crossover points.
Medical approaches
Large variety of papers addressed medical issues related to
tinnitus. Another modification for
treating Ménière’s disease is presented.
Several issues related to vestibular neuroma such as its prevalence,
confirming other reports that tinnitus occurs less often with increasing tumor
size (Heerma et al.), and recommendation of a conservative management of
unilateral vestibular schwannomas which coming from the group of Dr. Ugo Fisch
has a special meaning (Tschudi et al.).
Potential causes of tinnitus, from perilymphatic fistula to lighting and
car air bags explosion are presented.
Various source of somatosounds are reported as well. These papers mainly confirm and expand
previous findings.
Effects of exposing the
opened endolymphatic sac to large doses of steroids to treat intractable
Meniere's disease. Kitahara T, Takeda
N, Mishiro Y, Saika T, Fukushima M, Okumura S, Kubo T. Department of Otolaryngology, Osaka Rosai
Hospital, Sakai, Japan. Ann Otol Rhinol
Laryngol 2001 Feb;110(2):109_12
To enhance the effect of treatment for intractable Meniere's
disease, we exposed the opened endolymphatic sac to high concentrations of
steroids. This technique__endolymphatic sac drainage and steroid instillation
surgery__involves the application of a mass of prednisolone followed by
absorbable gelatin sponges soaked in a high concentration of dexamethasone into
a sac lumen opened and expanded with a bundle of absorbable gelatin film. These
sponges are also placed around the sac and coated with biochemical adhesive so
that the medicine is slowly delivered into the sac over a prolonged period of
time by means of a natural sustained_release vehicle. The short_term results (6
to 14 months) in 12 patients with Meniere's disease, including those in stage
IV, treated by the above techniques showed that definitive spells were
completely controlled in all cases. Hearing was improved, and annoyance due to
tinnitus was decreased in all cases except one.
Clinical picture of
vestibular schwannoma. Kentala E, Pyykko I
I. Department of Otolaryngology,
Helsinki University Central Hospital, PO Box 220, 00029 HYKS, Helsinki,
Finland. Auris Nasus Larynx 2001
Jan;28(1):15_22
Purpose: To characterize the clinical picture with vestibular
schwannoma, we retrieved 122 patients with vestibular schwannoma from the
vestibular unit of the Helsinki University Central Hospital. Procedures: The
patients filled out a questionnaire concerning their symptoms, earlier
diseases, accidents, and the use of tobacco and alcohol. This information was
then completed with results of audiometric, neurotologic and imaging studies.
The data were prospectively stored to the database of neurotologic expert
system called ONE. Results: The average tumor size was 21 mm. Most of the
patients had hearing loss (94%) and tinnitus (83%) but only half of them (49%)
had vertigo attacks. The most common initial symptom was hearing loss combined
with tinnitus (34%, n=44). Vertigo only was the initial symptom for 12
patients. The mean duration of a vertigo attack was from 5 min to 4 h and the
intensity of the attack was regularly mild (37%) or moderate (32%). The vertigo
of the vestibular schwannoma patients differed from vertigo in other diseases
by the absence (63%) or low intensity (18%) of nausea. Spontaneous nystagmus
was present in 56 patients (46%), and caloric asymmetry (>25%) was observed
in 66% (n=69). Caloric asymmetry increased with tumor size. The prevalence of
headache was 18% (n=21). Sudden slips seldom (7%) occurred. Conclusion: Hearing
loss and tinnitus are the main symptoms of vestibular schwannoma. Only half of
patients have vertigo. Screening to detect vestibular schwannoma is more
yielding in sudden deafness patients rather than in patients with Meniere's
disease.
Conservative management
of unilateral acoustic neuromas. Tschudi DC,
Linder TE, Fisch U. Department of
Otolaryngology, University Hospital of Zurich, Switzerland. Am J Otol 2000 Sep;21(5):722_8
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to analyze the natural
course of unilateral acoustic neuromas and to evaluate the advantages and
disadvantages of an initial conservative approach. METHODS: Between 1989 and
1994, 74 consecutive patients with the diagnosis of unilateral acoustic neuroma
were evaluated at the Department of Otorhinolaryngology, University of Zurich.
Their charts and magnetic resonance imaging scans were retrospectively analyzed
regarding duration and type of symptoms, initial tumor size, tumor growth
pattern, and audiometric data. RESULTS: Of the 74 tumors, 68.9% (51/74) did not
grow during a mean follow_up of 35 months. Eight (16%) of these tumors had
radiologically documented tumor regression. Twenty_three tumors did grow, 16 of
them (70%) with a growth rate of <2 mm/year. There was a statistically
significant correlation between the first_year and the total growth rate,
indicating that the tumor's behavior in the first year is highly predictive of
its subsequent growth pattern. Patients with progressive hearing loss as a
first symptom had a significantly lower tumor growth than those presenting with
tinnitus, sudden hearing loss, or dizziness. Patients with tumor growth showed
a greater tendency for hearing loss, although this trend was significant only
for isolated frequencies. In 12% of the cases (9/74), the initial conservative
approach had to be abandoned in favor of surgery. CONCLUSION: Watchful
expectation can be regarded as a safe approach for selected cases of acoustic
neuromas. Surgery or irradiation is indicated in patients with proven growth of
their tumors.
[Effect of
microneurosurgical operation in acoustic neurinoma on symptoms of vertigo and
tinnitus]. [Article in German] Heerma H, Braun V, Richter HP. Neurochirurgische Klinik, Universitat
Ulm. HNO 2000 May;48(5):372_7
After exstirpation of an acoustic neuroma one trends to
concentrated on the preservation of hearing and facial function. But how does
the surgical removal for an acoustic neuroma, influence the symptoms of tinnitus
and vertigo? Our report follows a retrospective evaluation of 78 patients.
Based on these results we will also discuss aspects of the origin of these
symptoms. Our patients suffered from tinnitus at a rate of 73% preoperatively
and 59% postoperatively. With increasing tumor size tinnitus occurred less
often, therefore we considered the size of the tumor exclusively. Also, an
intraoperative dissection of the cochlear nerve often did not result in an
improvement of the symptoms. Vertigo was stated prooperatively in 44% of the
cases, postoperatively in 22%. Again as with tinnitus, there was an inverse
relationship between the size of the tumor and the severity of the symptoms. In
conclusion a deafferention_like syndrome has to be considered as the major causative
factor for the tinnitus in patients with acoustic neuromas. However, in the
vertigo cases, the symptoms seem to be caused vestibularily due to the
increasing tumor and then after a temporary compensation a cerebellar ataxia
occurred which the patients often perceive as vertigo.
Perilymph fistula _ 45
case analysis. Goto F, Ogawa K, Kunihiro T,
Kurashima K, Kobayashi H, Kanzaki J.
Department of Otolaryngology, School of Medicine, Keio University,
Tokyo, Japan. Auris Nasus Larynx 2001
Jan;28(1):29_33
Purpose of the study: Though perilymph fistula (PLF) is not a
rare disease, preoperative diagnosis still remains to be established. Some new
diagnostic methods are challenging, but there is still no established
diagnostic method except exploratory tympanotomy that verifies the occurrence
of leakage. Early diagnosis of PLF is fully depending on history taking and
some clinical examinations. To know the clinical features of PLF is one of the
greatest helps to make both earlier and accurate diagnosis. In spite of some
innovations in clinical examinations classic diagnostic procedure is thought to
be still reliable. Procedures: We investigated the clinical symptoms, basic
tests results and therapeutic results in patients with PLF. Results: From 1983
to 1998 PLF was identified in 44 patients (45 ears) with exploratory
tympanotomies in our hospital. With respect to clinical history the
predisposing factors such as blowing the nose, lifting heavy goods, and landing
in an airplane were found in almost half of the patients, while the rest of
them had no clear inducing factors. Their major symptoms included hearing loss
(93%), vertigo and dizziness (91%), tinnitus (76%), and aural fullness (31%).
The patients who have a clear predisposing factor tended to make diagnosis
easily; on the other hand the rest of the patients who do not have clear
etiology had some diagnostic difficulty. Subjective positive fistula signs were
observed in 71% of patients. Vestibular symptoms improved in 80% of patients
after closure of PLF. Conclusions: These results suggest that the variety of
clinical manifestation make diagnosis more difficult. At the moment meticulous
clinical history taking and close follow_up applying repeating fistula tests
are the most important for not only earlier but also accurate diagnosis.
[Ear dysfunction due to
air bag detonation]? [Article in German] Brehmer D, Geidel O, Hesse G, Laubert
A. Universitats_HNO_Klinik
Witten/Herdecke, St. Marien_Hospital, Katholisches Krankenhaus Hagen gGmbH. HNO 2000 Oct;48(10):768_72
Air bags are among the latest developments in extensive
automobile safety systems. They successfully have saved the lives of car
occupants in road accidents. Many additional injuries caused by air bags from
minor to severe have been reported. With the help of two acceleration sensors,
the electronic tuner amplifier records the vehicle's deceleration. This is the
adequate trigger for air bag deployment, which creates an intense noise of up
to 170 dB sound pressure level. This noise level can cause cochlear damage. We
present two patients with otologic symptoms after spontaneous air bag
deployment.
[Bilateral acoustic
trauma after air bag inflation]. [Article in German] Fahimi_Weber S, Kessler A, Bakkal E, Siegert
R. Klinik fur Hals_Nasen_Ohren_Heilkunde,
Kopf_ und Hals_Chirurgie, Prosper Hospital Recklinghausen.
s.fahmi_weber@ruhr_uni_bochum.de HNO
2000 Oct;48(10):765_7
Airbag inflation is associated with a loud noise. This very
short noise has a peak amplitude of 170 dB sound pressure level and can make
otologic injuries. We report a case of acoustic trauma after airbag inflation.
The 24_year_old man has hearing loss both side in the 3000_ to 6000_Hz range
and in the deep_frequency. The possibility of acoustic trauma from airbag noise
are probably much more common and need more attention in the clinic.
Role of angiography in
the evaluation of patients with pulsatile tinnitus.
Shin EJ, Lalwani AK, Dowd CF.
Department of Otolaryngology__Head and Neck Surgery, University of
California, San Francisco, USA.
Laryngoscope 2000 Nov;110(11):1916_20
OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS: Pulsatile tinnitus in the face of
normal findings on otoscopy is a common otological diagnostic dilemma and can
be due to serious vascular malformations such as transverse or sigmoid sinus
dural arteriovenous fistula (transverse or sigmoid sinus [TS] DAVF). Left
untreated, TS DAVF may result in significant morbidity and mortality. TS DAVF
can be suspected or diagnosed with computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI), and magnetic resonance angiography (MRA), with the gold standard
being angiography. Our objective was to assess the utility of these various
diagnostic modalities in the diagnosis of dural arteriovenous fistula. STUDY
DESIGN: Retrospective clinical review. METHODS: Between 1986 and 1996, 54
patients were evaluated and treated for TS DAVF. Between 1996 and 1999, an
additional 33 patients underwent MRI combined with MRA for the evaluation of
pulsatile tinnitus. A retrospective review of the medical records for both
groups, with special attention to clinical presentation, diagnostic evaluation,
therapy, and outcome, was performed. RESULTS: All patients had pulsatile
tinnitus with normal findings on otoscopy. CT scan was relatively insensitive
in the detection of TS DAVF. MRI and MR/MRA were significantly more sensitive
than CT. In the evaluation of patients with subjective pulsatile tinnitus,
MRI/MRA defined anatomical abnormalities that may contribute to pulsatile
tinnitus in 63% of patients. CONCLUSIONS: In the absence of objective pulsatile
tinnitus, MRI/MRA is an appropriate initial diagnostic step. When a patient has
an objective bruit, the clinician may choose to proceed directly to angiography
to make certain that a TS DAVF is not missed.
Pulsatile tinnitus in
patients with morbid obesity: the effectiveness of weight reduction surgery. Michaelides EM, Sismanis A, Sugerman HJ,
Felton WL 3rd. Department of
Otolaryngology/Head Neck Surgery, Medical College of Virginia of Virginia
Commonwealth University, Richmond 23298, USA.
Am J Otol 2000 Sep;21(5):682_5
BACKGROUND: Morbid obesity is increasing in the United States
population. Morbidly obese patients may have disabling pulsatile tinnitus (PT)
secondary to pseudotumor cerebri syndrome and often seek treatment from
otolaryngologists because of this symptom. OBJECTIVE: To determine the
effectiveness of weight reduction surgery (WRS) for relief of PT in patients
with morbid obesity. STUDY DESIGN: Retrospective study of morbidly obese
patients with associated PT. SETTING: Academic tertiary referral center.
PATIENTS: Sixteen women with morbid obesity and associated PT who underwent
WRS. RESULTS: Median age was 34 years (range 24_45 years). Average preoperative
body mass index was 45 kg/m2 (range 33_70 kg/m2). Average weight loss was
45+/_17 kg (range 25_99 kg). Average postoperative weight was 75+/_14 kg (range
57_105 kg). The average preoperative cerebrospinal fluid pressure was 344+/_103
mm H2O (range 220_520 mm H2O). Postoperative measurements of cerebrospinal
fluid, obtained on 4 patients, revealed an average decrease in pressure of 198
mm H2O (range 120_400 mm H2O). Thirteen patients experienced complete
resolution of their PT (81%). Three patients continued to have PT despite
significant weight reduction. CONCLUSIONS: Weight reduction surgery was
effective in relieving PT in morbidly obese patients with associated
pseudotumor cerebri syndrome and should be considered when conservative
management has failed.
Middle_ear myoclonus. Zipfel TE, Kaza SR, Greene JS. Department of Otolaryngology_Head and Neck
Surgery, Penn State Geisinger Medical Center, USA. J Laryngol Otol 2000 Mar;114(3):207_9
Tinnitus produced by repetitive contraction of the middle_ear
muscles is a rare condition. We present an interesting case of bilateral
middle_ear myoclonus causing incapacitating tinnitus in a patient with multiple
sclerosis. Otological examination demonstrated rhythmic involuntary movement of
the tympanic membrane. These movements correlated with a rhythmic 'rushing
wind' noise perceived by the patient. Oropharyngeal examination showed no
evidence of palatal myoclonus. Impedance audiometry confirmed rhythmic change
in the middle_ear volume. Medical management was unsuccessful. The patient's
tinnitus was subsequently cured with bilateral sectioning of the tensor tympani
and stapedial tendons.
Intratympanic and
systemic dexamethasone for Meniere's disease.
Hirvonen TP, Peltomaa M, Ylikoski J.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Helsinki University Central Hospital,
Helsinki, Finland. timo.hirvonen@huch.fi
ORL J Otorhinolaryngol Relat Spec 2000 May_Jun;62(3):117_20
Intratympanic and systemic dexamethasone treatment of
Meniere's disease (MD) was evaluated in a prospective study. Seventeen patients
(6 men and 11 women) with MD (5 right_sided, 11 left_sided and 1 bilateral)
were treated with three 0.2_ to 0.4_ml injections of intratympanic
dexamethasone hyaluronate (16 mg/ml) during a week and with an initial
intramuscular dexamethasone injection of 15 mg. Most of patients were in stage
3, and the mean duration of MD was 5. 3 years. Pure_tone and speech audiometry
and the symptom scale of the patients were followed up for 1 year after the
treatment. Symptoms of aural fullness, hearing loss, tinnitus and vertigo did not
improve significantly. However, sufficient control of vertigo was achieved in
76% of the patients. In conclusion, no definite treatment effect has yet been
shown for intratympanic and systemic dexamethasone treatment. Therefore, the
clinical use of dexamethasone in MD needs further investigation. Copyright 2000
S. Karger AG, Basel
Ear injuries caused by
lightning: report of 18 cases. Gluncic I,
Roje Z, Gluncic V, Poljak K. Department
of Otorhinolaryngology, University Hospital Split, Croatia. J Laryngol Otol 2001 Jan;115(1):4_8
The clinical management and long_term outcome in lightning
survivors with substantial ear damage treated at the Department of
Otorhinolaryngology, University Hospital Split during the 1984_1999 period are
reviewed. Results of clinical management and outcomes of lightning ear damage
in 18 patients (mean age 35.3 +/_ 5 years) were retrospectively analyzed. On
admission, all patients complained of severe pain, tinnitus and hearing
impairment. Otomicroscopy revealed tympanic membrane rupture in 12 patients.
The active therapeutic approach included immediate otomicroscopy, aseptic
aspiration toilet, and eversion of perforation edges. In all patients, the
ruptures healed well, and restitution of the hearing function was achieved. Follow_up
examination performed in 1999 (13.2 +/_ 2.9 years later) in 11 patients (mean
age 52.3 +/_ 6.1 years) revealed an almost identical audiogram as on discharge
from the hospital, however, neuropsychological testing revealed numerous
sequelae. Tympanic injury caused by lightning should be actively treated.
Lightning survivors require additional psychotherapeutic treatment.
Psychology
Erlandson & Hallberg published interesting study
correlating quolity of life with number of variables. While several of them were predictable on the base of common
sense (feeling depressed, negative attitudes, etc.) unrespectably, fluctuation
in tinnitus, vertigo and headache did not contributed significantly to decrease
of life quality. Note, that even listed
6 variables explain only 65% of the variance.
While this is statistically significant the possibility that other
important factors were omitted need to be considered.
Possibility that tinnitus patients have impaired cognitive
performance was explored by Andersson et al.
The results indicate that this indeed might be a case, however, due to
methodology of the study, there is a possibility that hearing loss, and not
tinnitus, is responsible for the results.
Another study by Andersson et al. assess long term follow-up
of tinnitus complaints in patients seen by a psychologist. The interesting findings was that tinnitus
maskability could be used as a prognostic factor of future annoyance. As maskability is not a factor in case of
TRT treatment, this difference might be helpful in better understanding
differences of mechanisms involved in psychological treatments versus TRT.
Prediction of quality of
life in patients with tinnitus. Erlandsson
SI, Hallberg LR. Department of
Psychology, University of Goteborg, Sweden. Soly.Erlandsson@htu.se Br J Audiol 2000 Feb;34(1):11_20
According to epidemiological studies of tinnitus prevalence,
0.5_1% of respondents report that tinnitus severely affects their ability to
lead a normal life. In the present investigation quality of life and its
association with tinnitus_related factors: psychological, psychosomatic and
audiological, was studied based on a sample of 122 patients, who attended the hearing
clinic for distress due to tinnitus. A stepwise regression analysis was
performed with quality of life as a dependent variable. Six of 13 variables
included in the model proved to be significant regressors and to explain 65% of
the variance. The six predictor variables were: impaired concentration, feeling
depressed, perceived negative attitudes, hypersensitivity to sounds, average
hearing level (best ear) and tinnitus duration (the shorter the duration of
tinnitus the more negative impact on quality of life). The three most
significant predictors were directly related to perceived psychological
distress and explained most of the variance in quality of life in tinnitus
patients included in this study. An unexpected finding was that fluctuations in
tinnitus, vertigo, headache or perceived social support did not prove to belong
to the significant regressors. The results are discussed in view of the
construct of quality of life, depressive cognitions and social support in
general, as well as in tinnitus_specific life circumstances.
Tinnitus and cognitive
interference: a stroop paradigm study.
Andersson G, Eriksson J, Lundh LG, Lyttkens L. Department of Psychology, Uppsala University, Sweden.
gerhard.andersson@psyk.uu.se J Speech
Lang Hear Res 2000 Oct;43(5):1168_73
The aim of this study was to investigate cognitive
interference caused by tinnitus by means of a modified version of the Stroop
color_word test. In a mixed_design study, the performances of tinnitus patients
(n = 23) and healthy controls with normal hearing (n = 23) were compared on
three versions of the Stroop test: the original version, a modified version
including physical_threat words, and a tinnitus version for which tinnitus
words (descriptors of tinnitus; e.g., peep) were derived empirically. Matched
control conditions (words) were included for all three versions, yielding a
total of six screens that were presented on a computer. Participants in the
control group were matched with the patients for age and gender. Main dependent
measures were performance on the Stroop tests in terms of total time for
completing each test. Also included were the Tinnitus Questionnaire (TQ), the
Beck Depression Inventory (BDI), the state version of the Spielberger Trait
State Anxiety Inventory (STAI_S), and a subtest from the Wechsler Adult
Intelligence Scale measuring verbal ability. Results showed that tinnitus
patients performed significantly slower on all six test conditions. The
classical Stroop color_word interference was replicated in both groups. Also,
an effect for physical_threat words was found for both groups. Our expected
tinnitus word interference could not be established. Patients scored
significantly higher than controls on the BDI and the STAI, but these measures
did not correlate with the Stroop results. In conclusion, the results indicate
that tinnitus patients have impaired cognitive performance overall, as measured
by these variations of the Stroop paradigm, but hearing impairment cannot be
excluded as a possible confounder.
Longitudinal Follow_up of
Tinnitus Complaints. Andersson G,
Vretblad P, Larsen HC, Lyttkens L
Department of Psychology,
Uppsala University, Box 1225, SE_751 42 Uppsala, Sweden. Gerhard.Andersson@ psyk.uu.se Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2001
Feb;127(2):175_179
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the long_term outcome of patients
with tinnitus, the long_term effects of cognitive behavioral therapy, and what
properties of tinnitus predict distress at follow_up. DESIGN: A longitudinal
follow_up of a consecutive sample of patients with tinnitus initially seen by a
clinical psychologist. SETTING: Department of Audiology, University Hospital,
Uppsala, Sweden. PARTICIPANTS: A consecutive series of 189 patients with
tinnitus treated between January 1988 and March 1995 were sent a postal
questionnaire booklet. One hundred forty_six (77 women and 69 men) provided
usable responses, in all yielding a 77% response rate. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: A
questionnaire was derived from a structured interview "Questions About
Your Tinnitus." Also included were the Tinnitus Reaction Questionnaire and
tinnitus_matching data. RESULTS: Questionnaire data showed that many patients
with tinnitus still experienced distress an average of 4.9 years after
admission. Tolerance of tinnitus increased over time overall. For patients who
had received cognitive behavioral therapy (59%), there was a reduction in
tinnitus_related distress. Further, an open_ended question showed that the
benefits from treatment outnumbered the deficits. Multiple regression analysis
showed that tinnitus maskability at admission was a significant predictor of
distress at follow_up. CONCLUSIONS: Severe tinnitus shows some signs of
improvement over time, especially when psychological treatment has been given.
Tinnitus maskability is an important prognostic factor of future tinnitus
annoyance.